Brand Comparison

InSinkErator Badger 1 Vs Badger 5

We look at their similarities, differences & help you pick between Badger 1 Vs Badger 5.

by Josh Mitchell

There are many different brands of garbage disposals on the market today. With so many different options, how can you know what ones are most suited for you?  

One of the best garbage disposals out there is the InSinkErator. We would have to recommend the Badger 1 and 5 models. If you want to learn more about the Badger 1 vs Badger 5, make sure to stick around! 

The InSinkErator is a great budget option for anyone looking for a new garbage disposal. The product saves space with its compact design while still offering the heavy duty motor the brand is known for. Additionally, the product doesn't use any blades. 

Instead, the disposal pushes food waste into a grind ring, effectively breaking it down and destroying it. 

InSinkErator Garbage Disposal, Badger 1 HP,...
  • POWER GRIND PERFORMANCE: Features a long...

Badger 1 Pros & Cons 

  • Good option for any budget
  • Doesn’t jam or back up 
  • Super simple to set up with given instructions 
  • Works even with septic tanks
  •  Liquifies all food waste 
  • Extremely loud 
  • Doesn’t use stainless steel- rusts over time
  • Requires a separate cord for installation

InSinkErator Badger 5 Overview  

The InSinkerator Badger 5 is also an inexpensive option. It works best with smaller families and can provide you with consistent use. Additionally, the unit is easy to install on your own, making it great for anyone who wants to DIY this project. 

Many people buy this option for its size. However, you also get a much quieter model than the first one. If you don’t like loud noises, it’s the better option. 

InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal,...
  • RELIABLE & EASY INSTALL: Badger Series...
  • DURABLE COMPONENTS: This garbage disposal...
  • AMERICA'S #1 DISPOSER BRAND: There are more...
  • FASTER, CLEANER, SMARTER: From meal prep to...

Badger 5 Pros & Cons 

  • Lower noise levels 
  • Lasts up to 10 years 
  • Doesn’t take up much space under the sink 
  • Easy to install 
  • Comes with all the parts 
  • Minor leakage after years of use 
  • Unit housing can crack easily 
  • Issues with incorrect installation
  • Needs power cable 

InSinkErator Badger 1 Vs. Badger 5 (Key Differences Explained)

InSinkErator Garbage Disposal, Badger 1 HP,...
InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal,...
InSinkErator Garbage Disposal, Badger 1 HP,...
InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal,...
Amazon Prime
Amazon Prime
InSinkErator Garbage Disposal, Badger 1 HP,...
InSinkErator Garbage Disposal, Badger 1 HP,...
Amazon Prime
InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal,...
InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal,...
Amazon Prime

1. Food Grinding Capabilities

The Badger 5 is the better commercial garbage disposal when it comes to this benefit. It completely destroys all of the food, allowing it to easily pass through the plumbing afterward. If you need a more potent motor, the 5 is the better option for you.

2. Appearance & Dimensions

Both also look the same, although the 5 is slightly larger, due to its more powerful motor. These are their dimensions:

  • Badger 1: 11-3/8″ height, 6-5/16″ width, 13 lbs 
  • Badger 5: 12-5/8″ height, 6-5/16″ width, 14 lbs 

3. Noise Level

The Badger 5 is not nearly as loud as the previous models, making it great for a house with many people. If you dislike the sounds of garbage disposals, then you’ll want to go with this choice instead. 

4. Motor Power & Performance Options

The differences between the two models is actually quite small. Although, when it comes to the Badger 5 vs. the Badger 1, the 5 model usually comes out on top. It offers an enhanced performance, even though both options are very similar. 

5. Grinding Chamber Capacity

Both models offer a chamber capacity of 26oz. This is great for holding and disposing of larger amounts of food. The grinding chamber is made from galvanized steel. Unlike stainless steel, this material can rust or corrode over time. This is usually more of a problem with the 5 than it is with the 1. 

6. Impeller Quality

Both of these models also come with the same impeller system. However, the Badger 5 includes a much stronger motor. Because of this, it runs the impeller with ease and is much more efficient. The Badger 5 uses a ½ HP motor, while the 1 only uses a ⅓ HP motor.

7. Grinding Speed

When it comes to grinding speed, the two models have the same RPM. Although, due to the stronger motor, the Badger 5 offers a more reliable speed and strength. It’s sure to remove all food waste you offer.

8. Installation Process

InSinkErator uses an easy process with all of its models. They each use a quick lock sink mount, which makes it simple to upgrade from one Badger to the other if you need a replacement. So if you need to know if "Can I replace a Badger 1 with a Badger 5?", yes and it's very easy to do!

9. Price & Warranty

The differences in cost are minimal. However, the Badger 5 comes with a two year warranty, while the Badger 1 only has a single year warranty. If you want to ensure the model is covered for longer, then you should choose the option with the longer warranty - which would be the Badger 5.

People Also Ask (FAQs)

Who makes InSinkErator garbage disposals?  

Emerson Electric, which is located in Wisconsin, makes InSinkErator models. They are the largest manufacturer in this field, throughout the entire world. The brand is very well known in the United States. 

Which of these models is more popular?  

The Badger 5 is the much more popular option. It’s not much more expensive and comes with plenty of benefits- including a more powerful motor. 

Can I replace Badger 1 with a Badger 5 and vice versa?  

Yes, you can do this easily- all InSinkErator models are interchangeable. As a result, many people upgrade from the 1 to the 5 with minimal effort. 


InSinkErator is a household name for garbage disposals, but it can be hard to decipher the difference between their extensive line of models. Hopefully, this guide has helped you decide between the InSinkErator Badger 1 vs. InSinkErator Badger 5.  

Josh enjoys researching, testing and diving into home improvement & DIY products. He has a passion for tools, learning new skills and fixing the everyday problems that arise around the house.