Buyer's Guide & Information

Glacier Bay Toilet Reviews: Toilet Brand Comparisons

Find out which Glacier Bay high-efficiency toilet is best for your home.

by PlumberAndy

Buyer's Guide & Information

Glacier Bay Toilet Reviews: Toilet Brand Comparisons

Find out which Glacier Bay high-efficiency toilet is best for your home.

by PlumberAndy

by PlumberAndy
Best Round Toilet
Glacier Bay #N2428RB 2-Piece High-Efficiency Single Flush Round Toilet

Glacier Bay #N2428RB

Best Elongated toilet
Glacier Bay #N2428E 2-Piece High-Efficiency Single Flush Elongated Toilet

Glacier Bay #N2428E

Toilets are a pretty important part of life, and when they fail, no one is happy. This is why it's essential to select one of the best for your home. An easy way to ensure you’re receiving quality is by going with the Glacier Bay brand from Home Depot.

They produce various types of toilets, ranging from simple to high-tech. No matter which one you select, you can expect it to be ADA-compliant while providing excellent performance and durability. Typically, the products will be manufactured in China, Taiwan, or Israel, so you can also expect lower prices. 


Glacier Bay Toilet Types

  • One-Piece vs. Two-piece
    A one-piece toilet features a tank and bowl molded together to create a single unit. You'll find that these are generally smaller, making them ideal for smaller bathrooms. The two-piece models are more common and are comprised of a separate tank and bowl.
  • Single vs. Dual Flush
    Single flush systems are easier to use, but dual flushing provides either “half flushes” for just liquids and a full 1.6 gallons for solids. This not only gives you more control but allows you the option to save water, which shaves money off of bills and is eco-friendly.
  • Elongated vs. Round
    Elongated toilets are going to be more expensive and larger, but more comfortable and easier to use. If you have a smaller bathroom, then a round toilet may be the best option. It’s a more “traditional” style, and also less expensive. Round toilets also don’t have the strong flush that elongated models do.

What Makes the Glacier Bay Brand Popular?

With so many toilet brands out there, it can be challenging to stand out. However, Glacier Bay has managed to do so with apparent ease. It's not common to find quality at an affordable price, which this brand offers.

Not only that, but their designs are straightforward, have a minimalistic design that looks attractive in any home and come with easy-to-find parts. The products they create come in a wide variety of options, as well, so you can choose what works best for you and your household.


Buyer’s Guide to Choosing a Glacier Bay Toilet

Toilet Type

One-piece and two-piece toilets have many similarities, but many notable differences, as well. If you're limited on space, a 1-piece is recommended due to its more compact size. As they sit lower to the ground, they're also great for homes with small children. One-piece models are comprised of a solid unit, so there are fewer spaces to clean, making them easier to maintain.

The Glacier Bay 1-Piece 1.1 GPF High-Efficiency Dual Flush All-in-One is an excellent option if you want an easy-to-clean toilet. Two-piece models, on the other hand, are traditionally easier to repair but may not last as long, overall.

Bowl Shape

The most common toilet bowl shapes are round and elongated. Round bowls extend less into a room, which makes them preferable for smaller spaces. Elongated bowls are about two inches longer than round ones; offering added comfort and stability.

These are often more convenient for men to use and are also known to be a bit easier to clean. Many have less of a crevice around the underside of the bowl and are easier to see into the front side. A great example of this is the Glacier Bay 1-Piece Elongated All-in-One Toilet.

Drain Location/Rough-in Measurement

Before you purchase a product, you need to take the correct measurements to know where the water supply/drain is. To rough in your toilet, you'll need to bring the waste drain lines and water lines to the toilet, installing them correctly. If the measurements do not work with the toilet you've selected, then you could run into some serious problems.

Toilet Height

The standard height of a toilet is 15 inches, though "comfort" toilets are growing more popular and range from 17 to 19 inches high. As we live in a time where even young people are having knee and back issues, the added height can be an excellent stress reliever.

Also, taller people, the elderly, and those with mobility challenges may find higher toilets more appealing.  However, you may want to stick to something shorter if you have smaller members in your family/children.

Design

You'll find toilets that are made of ceramic, porcelain, and vitreous china. Each one is very durable, able to last for decades easily. Not only that, but it's very cheap to produce, so you don't have to empty your wallet for quality.

The real differences come in when speaking about barriers. Some use Sanigloss, which is a beautiful finish, while EverClean makes the surfaces smooth, with a gorgeous glaze. Barriers work to eliminate streaks and keeps the actual toilet free of oils and chemicals.

Water Saving Technology

Saving water isn't just important on your bill but the entire planet. That being said, opting for a toilet with water-saving technology can only be a positive. If you're unsure how much a toilet uses, take a look at its Flush Rating, which will tell you how many gallons of water is used per flush. A WaterSense Certification is reserved for those models which use 1.28 gallons per flush, or less.

Flushing Mechanism

Today, you'll commonly see one of the three flushing mechanisms: pull handles, single-push buttons, and dual-push buttons.

Pull handles are still very common, but somewhat outdated as you cannot control the amount of water released. Single-push buttons allow for much more control, with many even being able to stop the flow of water without having to wait for the cistern to empty 100%. The dual-push button is the most convenient, consisting of two buttons: a small and a larger one. The smaller button uses less water if you only need to flush liquid.

Price

In comparison with other brands, Glacier Bay models are usually less expensive. However, the toilets from the brand vary in pricing. One-piece elongated toilets will cost more, for example, than two-piece round toilets will. If the model comes with water-conserving technology or a dual-flush mechanism, you can expect to pay a bit more for that, too.

Warranty

Most are going to have a limited lifetime warranty, so you don’t have to worry about going without if something happens. I encourage registering your warranty on the Toto website, where you'll receive better service if you happen to run into an issue. Simply fill out the contact info, your product's details, personal information, and a bit about your home. 


Special Features of Glacier Bay Toilets

  • Glacier Bay Quick Connect
    This installation system makes it fast and easy to finish installation of your toilet, without the need for tools.
  • WaterSense and ADA Compliant
    WaterSense-certified products meet the EPA’s criteria for efficiency and performance, certified to use at least 20% less water, save energy, and perform better than non-certified models. ADA-compliant toilets sit 2 inches higher than your standard model, making it easier to use for those with disabilities.
  • Antimicrobial/SuperClean
    This anti-microbial glaze is added on to ensure you have a cleaner, healthier household and a toilet that looks better for longer.
  • Concealed Trapway
    The trap on these toilets are concealed, so instead of a molded trapway, you get a smooth surface which not only looks modern but is easier to clean.

5 Glacier Bay Toilet Models Reviewed

1. Glacier Bay #N2420

The Glacier Bay 1-Piece High-Efficiency Dual Flush Elongated All-in-One Toilet is the best one-piece I've seen on the market, and it's easy to see why. One of the biggest reasons why it ranks the top of the list is due to how compact it is for an elongated model. If you have a small space but want excellent comfort, then I can't recommend this model enough. Even if you have ample space, you'll enjoy the stability and modern looks the toilet offers.

Made with white vitreous china, you can expect its beauty to last for as long as you want it. Resistant to fading, cracking, and abrasions, it's the perfect model if you have kids and/or dogs in your home. Gentle, sleek curves make for a sophisticated design that compliments any bathroom while remaining sturdy. Moreover, the tank has a low profile, and the 1-piece design makes for quick cleaning.

The convenient top-mounted push button features two efficient options: 1.1 GPF for liquid, and 1.6 for full flushes. 1.1 GPF meets WaterSense criteria, saving more than 20% water per flush, which is very impressive. As the bowl height is 16.5 inches, it also complies with ADA’s accessibility requirements. If you’re taller or feel lower bowls strain your back and knees, this is a solid option for you.

Finally, the Glacier Bay 1 piece toilet also comes with a limited lifetime warranty, so you can rest easy knowing this model won’t let you down. Listed at the low price that it is, it’s easily positioned as the best.


2. Glacier Bay #N2428RB

The Glacier Bay 2-Piece High-Efficiency Single Flush Round Toilet is my favorite 2-piece model due to many of the reasons I liked the previous product. First of all, it’s incredibly durable, with a vitreous china composition that’s stain-and-abrasion-resistant. 

This is the model to get if you have small children in your household for that reason and others. Children often fit better with round models, as there's less of a chance of them falling in. A 2-inch fully glazed trap-way ensures it also stays more sanitary and cleaner, longer.

As it is a 2-piece, the bowl and tank are separate entities, which can make it slightly more tedious to clean with more nooks and crannies. If something is malfunctioning, however, the unit can be easier and quicker to fix.

The compact design is ideal for smaller spaces, as the round bowl doesn’t reach out as far as the elongated models do. With a 16.5-inch chair height bowl, it's precisely the same as the last product, which many prefer. 

While the single flush design provides 1.28 GPF high-efficiency operation, it still doesn’t allow for quite as much control as you’d get with a double. However, you will save water by having this toilet in your home as 1.28 is quite low.

The Glacier Bay high-efficiency toilet also comes with a limited lifetime warranty, so you're not risking much by selecting this model!


3. Glacier Bay #N2428E

If you don't have kids at home or are looking for extra comfort, then take a good look at this model. If you've read other toilet reviews, Glacier Bay often ranks high for this high-efficiency choice. Operating at 1.28 GPF, you'll easily use less water, which is important for every household.

A downside for me is that it doesn't use a button, but rather a pull handle. This means that you'll have less control over how much water is used, but that may not be a big deal to you. The good news is that the meticulously-engineered bowl design offers flush power rarely seen in products of this price point.

The vitreous china body is made to withstand years upon years of use and is resistant to stains, acid, abrasions, and much more. The glazed trap-way also helps to keep the toilet sparkling clean because hygiene is of the utmost importance.

I found this design one of the easiest to install, which comes with a toilet seat, wax ring, and floor mounting bolt seat. The brand's QuickConnect system simplifies it so much, that even if it's your first time installing a toilet, you'll have no issues. No tools are required and included instructions are straightforward and easy to follow. 


4. Glacier Bay #N2430E

If saving water is your top priority when choosing a toilet, none can compete with the Glacier 2-Piece 1.0 GPF/1.28 GPF High-Efficiency Dual Flush Elongated model. The dual flush mechanism is located conveniently at the top and comes with two buttons.

The smaller uses just one gallon of water for liquid flushes and 1.28 for full flushes, which is extremely conservative, even for this brand. As you can imagine, it more than fits within the requirements of being WaterSense-certified.

The chair comes in at 16.5 inches, which is a bit higher than the standard, also making it ADA-compliant for those who can't use lower ones comfortably. Overall, the model is quite attractive with an elongated vitreous china toilet bowl and chrome-plated inset push buttons. The two-piece model is slightly more challenging to keep clean, but overall looks sleek and sophisticated.

Going back to the seat style, this perhaps the most attractive part of the model aside from its efficiency. The elongated bowl is excellent for men and women, providing extra space to eliminate the risk of mess while adding stability.

In addition to everything else, the fact that the Glacier Bay dual flush toilet comes with a limited lifetime guarantee makes it practically impossible to turn down.


5. Glacier Bay #N2428R-DF

Perhaps you want to be frugal with your water use, but don't like the elongated bowl designs. That's just fine because I have the perfect alternative for you: the 2-Piece 1.1 GPF/1.6 GPF Dual Flush Round Toilet. While it's not quite as low as the single gallon the last product uses, 1.1 GPF isn't too far off.

The top-mount push button makes it easy to control water output with the pressure of your fingers, so your water bill is sure to drop significantly. Use the smaller for liquid, and the larger button for full flushes.

The 2-piece toilet is perfect if you're limited on space, as well. The narrow profile fits nicely, even in tiny bathrooms. The round bowl doesn't extend as much as the elongated models do, while also helping smaller children feel more secure. However, remember that the bowl height is 16.5 inches, which may be a bit tall for some. Made of durable, crack-resistant China, it’s sure to hold up well, even through wear-and-tear over the years.

Coming with a toilet seat, wax ring and floor mounting bolt set, you have everything you need to install the toilet, and the QuickConnect System only makes it easier, with no tools required. 


Glacier Bay Toilets Compared

Model

Toilet Type

Seat Shape

Dimensions

Flushing System

Water Consumption

(GPF)

1-Piece

Elongated

29.54 x 28.37

x 16.64

Dual

1.1/1.6

2-Piece

Round

27.5 x 32.5

x 18.13

Single

1.28

2-Piece

Elongated

29 x 32.5

x 18.5

Single

1.28

2-Piece

Elongated

29.8 x 31.1

x 18.5

Dual

1.0/1.28

2-Piece

Round

28.5 x 33.75

x 18

Dual

1.1/1.6


Glacier Bay Flushing Systems Explained

There are an array of different flushing systems, and it's essential to know the difference between them.

The gravity flush system uses the water to make the flushing pressure, forcibly moving everything from the tank and bowl through the trap-way. This system is the oldest of the bunch and is still commonly-used due to the low maintenance it requires due to lack of other moving parts. 

Siphonic jet systems feature a hole towards the bottom of the bowl, which enables a considerable amount of water to enter the bowl quickly, essentially creating a siphoning action to pull waste from the bowl. There's also a siphon tube often called a "p-trap", which is curved to prevent gases from coming back into the bathroom while creating a partial vacuum inside part of the tube. This type is probably the most popular currently. 

Flapper-flush systems feature an outlet at the bottom of the tank covered by a floating “flapper” which is kept in place against a fitting by water pressure. Once you flush the toilet, it lifts the valve from the valve seat and floats, letting the tank quickly empty into the bowl. As water level lowers, the valve floats back to the bottom of the tank, once again covering the outlet pipe.

You'll find each of these systems in the products listed above. Which one you select is entirely up to you and your personal preference.


Comparisons with Other Brands

Glacier Bay has its appeal, but that's not to say there aren't other great brands out there.

Toto is one of the most well-known, due to the high level of quality they consistently produce. While they're also eco-friendly, like Glacier Bay, their products are often very costly which many consumers cannot afford. They also usually come with features that many don't need or even want, such as sensor-controlled seats and water temperature control.

Kohler is quite possibly the most similar brand to Glacier Bay, with overall robust, durable and efficient designs. However, Kohler is notorious for creating minor but annoying issues, like clogging and even leaking. They're a bit more comfortable, but also more expensive.

Finally, American Standard is also up there with the other brands. The style, efficiency, and durability are good, but it's also more expensive while offering very similar designs to Glacier Bay. The brand is used in hotels, businesses, homes, and even stadiums, so expect these to provide raw toughness.


Installation of Glacier Bay Toilets

Firstly, if you can’t comfortably move 80 pounds, you should have someone help you install your toilet as these are heavy.

  • 1
    Put the plastic flange on the drain, screwing it to the floor. Then, slip the anchor bolts into the slots and place the wax ring around the hole you’ll find on the underside of the toilet.
  • 2
    Next up, you'll want to lift your toilet squarely, lifting and lowering it onto the anchor bolts. To ensure the wax ring is set correctly, sit down on your toilet, gently moving back and forth. After this, hand-tighten the nuts onto the anchor bolts, and give them a little nudge with an adjustable wrench to ensure they're secure.
  • 3
    To remove extra anchor bolt, tap it with your wrench, screwing on the bolt cap.
  • 4
    Lift up the tank, placing it onto the bowl. Make sure the tank’s bolt holes are correctly aligned with those at the top-back of the bowl. Once guided in, tighten them by holding the tank nut bolt with a wrench while tightening the bolt with a screwdriver.
  • 5
    Place the shutoff valve over the compression ring, hand-tightening the nut. After this, take the smaller end of the plastic supply line and connect it to the shutoff valve and the opposite end to the bottom of the tank. Hand-tighten each end.
  • 6
    Align the holes at the rear of the toilet seat with those on the bowl. Insert the seat bowls, tightening them with your screwdriver while keeping the nut in your other hand.
  • 7
    Finally, turn on the water at the main, turn on the toilet shutoff valve and fill the tank. Place the tank lid on, and flush.

The entire process usually takes around one or two hours; however, getting a professional plumber to install it for you can make the experience much more straightforward. This usually costs about $125, but it is more than worth just that.

A plumber will ensure no water damage happens, which can easily cost thousands of dollars. They make sure that the toilet is correctly installed, and can also take a look to see if any of your existing plumbing pipes or lines need to be repaired or modified to fit your new toilet.


Toilet Maintenance Tips

To have your toilet looking and operating well for as long as possible, it's essential to take care of it. Here are some tips for doing so:

  • 1
    Clean the tank:
    Over time, the tank can create buildup. If your tank is dirty, then that water goes right into the toilet bowl, which can make the entire toilet challenging to keep clean. If you can, try to clean it once every two months or so.
  • 2
    Clean the bowl:
    This is pretty obvious, but it is vital to prevent corrosion and clogging. Instead of pricey chemical cleaners, opt for a more natural mixture of vinegar, baking soda, and water. This will not only keep it white and clean but will eliminate any potential foul odors. Using a toilet brush and this mixture at least once a week will keep it looking and smelling fresh.
  • 3
    Check for leaks:
    As you’re cleaning, make sure to check for wet areas on and around the toilet, as well as the water line which connects the toilet to the wall. You can also do so by adding a few drops of food coloring to your tanks and letting them sit for half an hour. It the water in the toilet changes color, you have a leak.
  • 4
    Check the fill valve works well:
    Take off the tank lid and flush. Make sure that after the tank has refilled, the fill valve stops dispensing water.

While you can probably perform maintenance on your own, I always recommend a plumber do so. This way, they can check everything completely and thoroughly, saving you from potential costly disasters.


Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if I need replacement parts for my Glacier Bay toilet?

If you cannot stop water from leaking out of the tank, you may need a new flush valve. A flush valve is a 2-inch device which lifts up when you push the toilet handle down. Changing it can be quite simple, but many prefer to have a professional do so.

What is the safest way to remove hard water stains and mold from my Glacier Bay toilet?

To remove hard water stains, get some distilled white vinegar, baking soda, paper towels, and a scrub sponge. Soak six paper towels with the vinegar, roll them up, and place them under the toilet rim. Press firmly, and they'll stay there. Leave them for at least 30 minutes, then remove and toss away.

Next, take a tablespoon of baking soda and place on a damp sponge, scrubbing where the paper towels were. The hard water stains will be loosened up by now, and come off relatively easy. If they don’t, simply spray with a bit more vinegar, add more baking soda, and repeat.

For mold, get some rubber gloves, and try to drain out as much water as you can. Next, clean the bowl as you normally would, using a toilet brush to loosen the mold. Flush and repeat until it appears to have disappeared. Then, pour a cup of bleach into the bowl and let sit for up to 30 minutes. Flush and clean the bowl once again. Finally, clean other toilet areas, spraying a disinfectant on exterior surfaces and the seat.

What should I do if I smell an odor in my Glacier Bay toilet?

Take some baking soda, lemon juice, and vinegar and clean the areas in and around the toilet. If this doesn't fix the issue, the toilet could be clogged, and you'll need to clear it. If this still doesn't work, call a plumber.

Can I add a Bidet to an existing toilet?

Yes, you can. In fact, these are quite easy to install, even if you have no previous DIY experience.

What is the price range of the toilets on our list?

They range from under $100, all the way to approximately $800.

Where is a good place to buy a new toilet?

Going to Home Depot may be the most convenient option for most, but you can also go to their website, or Amazon is another excellent option.


Conclusion

Now that you’re a Glacier Bay toilet expert, which one will you be installing in your home? While all of the above products are highly recommended, none can match the Glacier Bay 1-Piece All-in-One Toilet, in my opinion. It’s affordable, long-lasting, features a sleek design and is very comfortable. 

Not only that, but it’s incredibly eco-friendly and allows you to have full control over the amount of water you use. If you have a smaller space, then I’d opt for the Glacier Bay 2-Piece which has many similarities with the former. What’s most important, though, is that you select the perfect product for you. I hope that this article has helped you do just that.

Last Updated on

Top